JunawadiAll records

All records · Attribution and framing

Attribution and framing

Who the bounds series is by

The Moon through the Bounds Apr 22, 2024 · Olomi’s post

A OLOMI’S STATED ATTRIBUTION

“What follows is a translation from Junawadi on the planets through the Bounds. They are sourced originally from al-Khayyat, against whom we’ve checked the translation.”

B SOURCE LOCATED FOR COMPARISON

Māshāʾallāh

Māshāʾallāh, On the Significations of the Planets in a Nativity, ch. 20–26 (Heller 1549)

Dykes, Works of Sahl & Māshāʾallāh, pp. 381 and 390

Difference

OLOMI’S QUOTATION IN FULL

What follows is a translation from Junawadi on the planets through the Bounds. They are sourced originally from al-Khayyat, against whom we’ve checked the translation. Here we can see a clear continuity from Mash’allah down through the medieval astrologers that succeeded him.

Presented in quotation marks in the post.

LOCATED PASSAGES WITH SOURCE CONTEXT

COMPARED SOURCE

Māshāʾallāh

Dykes, Works of Sahl & Māshāʾallāh, pp. 381 and 390

English translation: Dykes, Works of Sahl & Māshāʾallāh (2008). The images use the PDF’s pagination; the citation above follows the printed book.

Chapter 20: On the signification of Saturn, when he is in his own bounds or those of other planets, in the nativity. Chapter 26: On the signification of the Moon in her bounds.

CITED EXCERPT

Cited source passage

Dykes 2008, p. 361

Excerpt retained in the comparison notes.

The twentieth, on the signification of Saturn when he is in his own or others' bounds

CITED EXCERPT

Cited source passage

Dykes 2008, p. 361

Excerpt retained in the comparison notes.

The book of Māshāʾallāh on the significations of the planets in a nativity, of which these are the chapters:

2 annotations. Select a highlight or an annotation below to follow the comparison.

ANNOTATIONS
All clause comparisons 2

OLOMI

“They are sourced originally from al-Khayyat, against whom we've checked the translation.”

SOURCE · Dykes 2008, p. 361

“The twentieth, on the signification of Saturn when he is in his own or others' bounds”

The seven matched installments render chapters 20 to 26 of Māshāʾallāh's own treatise, whose chapter list names them here. Al-Khayyāṭ's Kitāb al-mawālīd was compared cell by cell and does not carry them.

OLOMI

“Here we can see a clear continuity from Mash'allah down through the medieval astrologers that succeeded him.”

SOURCE · Dykes 2008, p. 361

“The book of Māshāʾallāh on the significations of the planets in a nativity, of which these are the chapters:”

The text on the page is Māshāʾallāh's, not a successor's rendering of him, so the continuity Olomi exhibits is the source itself.

Māshāʾallāh: Benjamin N. Dykes, trans., Works of Sahl & Māshāʾallāh (Minneapolis: Cazimi Press, 2008), from the 1549 Latin.

Search account and related passages

Quotations from Ali A. Olomi’s posts and from the cited editions are reproduced under fair use for comparison, criticism and commentary. This site has no analytics or advertising, and is strictly non-commercial. Quoted material remains the property of its respective authors and publishers.