JunawadiAll records

All records · Attribution and framing

Attribution and framing

Where the technique came from

Summer Moons in Medieval World Astrology Jul 17, 2022 · Olomi’s post

A OLOMI’S STATED ATTRIBUTION

“Isfahani states it was a technique among the people of Hind which is fascinating as it relies on the ingress of the Sun into tropical Cancer.”

B SOURCE LOCATED FOR COMPARISON

Tanbīhāt al-munajjimīn

The chain the book gives for the Sirius judgments

Tanbīhāt · p. 265, lines 17–20

DifferenceSource only

OLOMI’S QUOTATION IN FULL

The technique likely derives from Abu Ma’shar as it is popular among his students and lineage, but its actual source may be India.

Stated in prose in the post.

LOCATED PASSAGES WITH SOURCE CONTEXT

COMPARED SOURCE

The chain the book gives for the Sirius judgments

Tanbīhāt · p. 265, lines 17–20

Preliminary English AI translation of the Persian text. Images show the 1868 lithograph; references follow the digitized copy’s page and line numbering.

Page:line references at left. Adjacent context is muted.

265:12

of Mercury, there will be much talk among the people, and accusation and calumny, especially in Gemini, and to accounting and bookkeeping

265:13

and to bureaucratic disputes they will be inclined. And if it is in the house of the Moon, rain will come in its time, and the opening of the affairs of

265:14

the common people will be, and news will come. (Chapter Two on the judgments of Sirius) And the Arabs call it Shi'ra

265:15

al-'Ubur, and the Persians Ruz Ahang, and the Turks Quruq, and a star brighter and greater than it among

265:16

the fixed stars there is not. And at this time on the night of the seventeenth of the month of Murdad of the Jalali calendar it rises. Hermes the Sage

265:17

at the time of its rising has given judgments for the occurrence of the Moon in each of the twelve signs, and Niftawayh the Sage has

265:18

transmitted it from the ancient tongue into the Arabic language, and Aristotle has extracted it from the book Makhzan al-Asrar, and the people

265:19

of Harran have considered it among the mysteries of the introduction to knowledge, and we have transmitted it with a clear expression in this book

265:20

so that the people of this art may benefit from it, God willing. So if at the time of the rising of Sirius (the Moon is in Aries)

Persian transcription

عطارد بود کثرت گفتگوی مردم باشد و تهمت و بهتان خاصه در جوزا و بحساب و کتاب و بخصومتهای دیوانی مایل باشند و اگر در خانه قمر باشد در وقتش باران اید و فتح کارهای عوام الناس باشد و خبرها اید (فصل دوم در احکام شعرای یمانی) و او را عرب شعر عبور و فرسنیان روز آهنگ و اتراک قوروق گویند و کوکبی از او روشن تر و عظیم تر در میان ثوابت نیست و در این زمان در شب هفدهم مرداد ماه جلالی طلوع میکند هرمس حکیم در وقت طلوع او وقوع قمر را در هر یک از بروج اثنی عشر احکام فرموده و نفطویه حکیم انرا از لسان قدیم بلغه عربی نقل کرده و ارسطاطالیس استخراج از کتاب مخزن الاسرار کرده و اهل حران انرا از غوامض مقدمه معرفت دانسته اند و ما انرا بعبارتی موضح در این کتاب نقل کردیم تا اهل این فن از ان مستفید گردند انشاء الله تعا پس اگر در وقت طلوع شعرا (قمر در حمل بود)

Page and line references

PAGE 265 · LINES 12–20

12of Mercury, there will be much talk among the people, and accusation and calumny, especially in Gemini, and to accounting and bookkeeping

13and to bureaucratic disputes they will be inclined. And if it is in the house of the Moon, rain will come in its time, and the opening of the affairs of

14the common people will be, and news will come. (Chapter Two on the judgments of Sirius) And the Arabs call it Shi'ra

15al-'Ubur, and the Persians Ruz Ahang, and the Turks Quruq, and a star brighter and greater than it among

16the fixed stars there is not. And at this time on the night of the seventeenth of the month of Murdad of the Jalali calendar it rises. Hermes the Sage

17at the time of its rising has given judgments for the occurrence of the Moon in each of the twelve signs, and Niftawayh the Sage has

18transmitted it from the ancient tongue into the Arabic language, and Aristotle has extracted it from the book Makhzan al-Asrar, and the people

19of Harran have considered it among the mysteries of the introduction to knowledge, and we have transmitted it with a clear expression in this book

20so that the people of this art may benefit from it, God willing. So if at the time of the rising of Sirius (the Moon is in Aries)

4 annotations. Select a highlight or an annotation below to follow the comparison.

ANNOTATIONS
All clause comparisons 4

OLOMI

“likely derives from Abu Ma'shar”

SOURCE · Tanbīhāt page 0265:17–18

“and Niftawayh the Sage has transmitted it from the ancient tongue into the Arabic language”

Four steps of transmission are named here, from Hermes through Niftawayh, and no Abu Ma'shar among them.

OLOMI

“its actual source may be India”

SOURCE · Tanbīhāt page 0265:18–19

“and Aristotle has extracted it from the book Makhzan al-Asrar, and the people of Harran have considered it among the mysteries of the introduction to knowledge”

The chain runs to a named book and to the people of Harran. India is nowhere in it.

OLOMI

No counterpart recorded in the quotation.

SOURCE · Tanbīhāt page 0265:16–18

“Hermes the Sage at the time of its rising has given judgments for the occurrence of the Moon in each of the twelve signs, and Niftawayh the Sage has transmitted it from the ancient tongue into the Arabic language”

OLOMI

No counterpart recorded in the quotation.

SOURCE · Tanbīhāt page 0265:18–19

“and Aristotle has extracted it from the book Makhzan al-Asrar, and the people of Harran have considered it among the mysteries of the introduction to knowledge”

the Tanbīhāt: Preliminary AI translation; compare with the Persian and page image.

Search account and related passages

Quotations from Ali A. Olomi’s posts and from the cited editions are reproduced under fair use for comparison, criticism and commentary. This site has no analytics or advertising, and is strictly non-commercial. Quoted material remains the property of its respective authors and publishers.